After a Strong Rebound, Valuations Put Stock Selection Back in Focus
The market strategist sees a firmer foundation for Indian equities, but says November’s rally has narrowed the cushion for investors.
Sahil Kapoor of DSP Mutual Fund is more constructive on Indian equities than he was two years ago, citing improved valuations and a more reasonable earnings hurdle. But after the Nifty gained close to 10% in November, he argues that investors should be selective, focusing on areas where valuations and expectations have reset.
The earnings story remains intact, but the valuation premium has eased
Kapoor’s case for India rests partly on the consistency of its corporate earnings. From 2010 to 2025, Indian earnings per share compounded at 9.1%, with only three down years in 16. That steadiness, however, has not guaranteed market outperformance. Investors have also rewarded exposure to fast-growing themes: Taiwan and South Korea benefited from the artificial-intelligence hardware cycle, while Indian equities did not have the same direct exposure.
Since 2019, Indian EPS has grown around 17.5% annually, compared with roughly 10.7% for the index. In Kapoor’s reading, the gap points to a valuation reset rather than a breakdown in earnings. He also cautions against assuming that the post-pandemic profit surge will repeat: balance-sheet repair, lower interest costs and margin expansion did much of the work, and margins are now closer to cyclical highs.
That shifts the focus towards sales growth. Kapoor sees scope for earnings to compound in the high-single-digit to low-double-digit range, supported by economic growth and structural factors including credit growth, formalisation, manufacturing investment, premiumisation and services exports. These are supports, not guarantees: companies still need to convert demand and investment into revenue and profits.
The rally has reduced, not erased, the valuation case
Kapoor said the market had corrected through prices, time and earnings. The Nifty’s one-year forward earnings multiple fell from around 21.5 times in September 2024 to roughly 17.4 times by September 2026. On trailing earnings, the Nifty 50 stood at 20.5 times on November 13, about 6% below its five-year median and nearly 12% below its 10-year median.
He also noted that Nifty earnings grew about 12% annually over five years, while prices rose around 6.8%. The November rebound, which he linked to capital rotating back towards India as global AI enthusiasm cooled, changes the near-term balance: lower valuations and subdued expectations may support the market, but a sharp rise can quickly reduce the margin of safety. That makes buying indiscriminately less attractive.
Private banks stand out, while other beaten-down themes need proof
Private banks are among Kapoor’s preferred areas because their stock performance has lagged business growth. Major private banks traded at around 2.1 times book value, against a 10-year average closer to 3.1 times, while reporting average return on equity of about 16% and net non-performing assets of roughly 0.4%. In Q2 FY27, the group recorded around 19.8% year-on-year profit growth, with credit growth of about 19.6% and deposit growth of 21%.
Margins weakened in the quarter, partly because banks had raised FCNR(B) deposits that were not yet fully deployed. Kapoor sees potential for some of that drag to ease as funds are deployed or replace more expensive deposits, though stabilisation is not assured. Large-cap IT also interests him after weak returns and lower expectations, but AI remains both an opportunity and a risk. He is more cautious on consumer staples and cement until earnings accelerate more clearly.
Promoter sales call for scrutiny, not an automatic exit
Kapoor advises investors not to treat promoter selling as a mechanical sell signal. A sale can reflect diversification, succession, regulatory requirements, private-equity exits or personal liquidity needs. The more useful questions are how much is being sold, what stake remains, the valuation at the time and the reason for the transaction. Selling is evidence investors can examine, he said, but not a verdict on a company.
Key Highlights
- Kapoor is more constructive on Indian equities, but says the November rally has reduced the margin of safety.
- India’s earnings record remains consistent, although the next phase of growth may depend more on sales than further margin expansion.
- Private banks combine relatively subdued valuations with credit growth and strong asset quality, while margin stabilisation remains a key watchpoint.
- Large-cap IT is on the radar, but AI-related risks and opportunities make selectivity important.
- Promoter selling should prompt investors to reassess valuation and transaction details, rather than trigger an automatic exit.
Investor Note: Kapoor’s views offer a framework, not a portfolio prescription. Investors should assess each holding’s valuation, earnings outlook and risks independently, and avoid treating either a market rebound or promoter selling as a stand-alone investment signal.
Stay Ahead of the Market 📈
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
Get your weekly market summary from FinBrooks Insights and smart financial lessons from FinBrooks Academy delivered straight to your inbox every weekend!