India’s FPI Tax Debate Puts Global Competitiveness in Focus
A possible change to capital gains taxation could reshape the cost of investing in Indian equities, but the case for relief is balanced by concerns over fairness and tax neutrality.
The government is examining whether to change the long-term capital gains tax paid by foreign portfolio investors, with any decision expected in the Budget. India’s approach differs from several large markets that generally do not tax non-resident portfolio gains, while proposals for relief raise questions about how foreign and domestic investors should be treated.
The tax structure under review
Foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) currently pay the same tax rates as resident investors on listed equities. Gains on shares held for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% above an annual threshold of Rs 1.25 lakh, while gains on holdings of up to 12 months are taxed at 20%.
The cost does not end with capital gains tax. FPIs also pay securities transaction tax of 0.1% on both the purchase and sale of delivery-based shares, regardless of whether a transaction produces a profit. That distinction matters: transaction taxes apply to trading activity, while capital gains tax is tied to gains.
The Finance Ministry is examining representations on the structure. Sebi has reportedly recommended scrapping the LTCG tax for FPIs, but its recommendation is not binding. CBDT chairman Ravi Agrawal has said any decision will be taken only in the Budget, due in February 2027.
How India differs from other markets
The comparison with overseas markets is central to the debate. The United States, United Kingdom and Germany generally do not tax non-residents’ portfolio gains, while China exempts foreign investors from corporate income tax on gains from mainland-listed A-shares under an administrative arrangement in place since 2014. The exemption is temporary in form, though it has continued for more than a decade.
Those examples strengthen the argument that India’s treatment may affect the relative attractiveness of its equity market to global capital. But the comparison is not, by itself, proof that removing the tax would bring in investment: capital allocation can reflect several considerations, and the material provided does not quantify how much investor behaviour is driven by taxation.
Competitiveness versus equal treatment
Marcellus Investment Managers founder Saurabh Mukherjea argues that the effective burden is higher than the headline rate. He estimates that adding STT, surcharge and GST takes it to about 15%, and says funds’ provisions for future tax can raise the overall cost to 16–16.5%. He also points to the MSCI India index’s dollar returns after taxes and estimates foreign outflows of about $70 billion over two years. These are his assessments, rather than government estimates.
Grant Thornton Bharat’s Akhil Chandna cautions against a blanket exemption. One possible middle path, in his view, would distinguish genuine long-term institutional investors from short-term speculative activity, with holding-period and anti-abuse conditions. Such a design could target the competitiveness concern while retaining a tax charge on shorter-term gains.
The policy choice also has a distributional dimension. Exempting foreign investors while domestic investors continue to pay could raise questions about tax neutrality; extending relief more broadly would have different implications. The Budget decision will therefore matter not only for the cost faced by FPIs, but also for how the government balances attracting capital with consistent treatment across investors.
Key Highlights
- FPIs currently face the same listed-equity capital gains rates as residents.
- Delivery-based share transactions also attract 0.1% STT on both purchase and sale.
- Several major markets generally do not tax non-residents’ portfolio gains; China has an exemption for A-share gains.
- A possible targeted concession for long-term institutional FPIs has been raised as an alternative to a blanket exemption.
- The government says any decision will come in the Budget, due in February 2027.
Investor Note: The tax debate is relevant to the cost and policy framework for foreign investment, but no change has been confirmed. Investors should distinguish proposals and stakeholder estimates from the final Budget decision, and avoid treating tax relief as a guaranteed trigger for capital flows or market returns.
Stay Ahead of the Market 📈
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
Get your weekly market summary from FinBrooks Insights and smart financial lessons from FinBrooks Academy delivered straight to your inbox every weekend!